Claimants supplying labor or materials to the general or its 1st-tier subs, but possibly ALL furnishers of labor or materials are covered. [507-42; Schor at §12.03[B]] NOTE that contractors and subs must be licensed in order to have lien rights or the right to sue for breach of contract, and a sub or sub-sub will only have lien rights if the general and first-tier sub were licensed. There is, however, a new exemption to the licensing rule for owners or lessees who build or improve their own residence or farm, or those of the members of their immediate family, as long as the buildings are not being offered for sale or lease, unless the sale or lease is to an employee of the owner, is due to hardship, or the repairs cost less than $10,000. There is a process set out for obtaining this exemption that must be followed. Note that the owner-builder must still hire licensed subs, and all electrical and plumbing work must still be done by licensed electricians or plumbers. [444-22; 507-49(b); 444-2.5; 444-A] For materials supplied to a project on property that was primarily RESIDENTIAL before improvements began, a supplier has lien rights only as long as they supplied to a LICENSED general or sub, and as long as the credit extended was not unreasonable. On these residential projects, it is essential that a supplier obtain a credit application from its customer, and it is strongly advised that supplier make some reasonable inquiry into customer’s credit status, prior to selling to customer. Note also that where a supplier is aware of a contractor’s precarious financial situation, the supplier has a duty to warn the owner. If the supplier fails to warn the homeowner, they may not be allowed to enforce their lien against the homeowner. [507-49; Reliable Collection Agency, Ltd. v. Aquarius Indus., Inc., 5 P.2d 129 (1975)]
1. Who May Have A Lien?
Private:
Public:
All suppliers of labor or material to the contractor. NOTE THAT this statute is intended to follow the federal statute, the Miller Act, and any questions of interpretation should be resolved by reviewing interpretations of that statute. [103D.324] NOTE ALSO that various state and county agencies have adopted regulations that elaborate on the statute and administrative rules. These are available through the Div. of Public Works, Dept of Accounting and General Services for the State of Hawai’i; the Divisions of Air and Water Transportation for the State of Hawai’i, and the General Conditions of Construction Contracts of the City and County of Honolulu, Dept. of Finance. It would be advisable to check with whatever public body is letting the contract to find out if they have any supplemental regulations. [Schor update at §12.01]
2. What Is The Lien Against?
Private:
The improvement and the interest of the owner. [507-42]
Public:
The contractor’s payment bond. [103D-324]
3. Who Must Give The Preliminary Notice?
Private:
A licensed general contractor contracting with a homeowner or lessee on a contract involving home construction or improvements to residential property, including condominiums and cooperatives. These notices apparently must be given even where the homeowner is a sophisticated developer, fully educated about lien and bond rights. [444-25.5; 808 Development, LLC v. Murakami, 141 P.3d 996 (Hawaii, 2006)]
Public:
A preliminary notice is not required.
4. To Whom Is The Preliminary Notice Given?
Private:
The homeowner or lessee. The notices must be given even where the homeowner is a sophisticated developer, fully educated about lien and bond rights [444-25.5; 808 Development, LLC v. Murakami, 141 P.3d 996 (Hawaii, 2006)]
Public:
Not applicable.
5. When Must Preliminary Notice Be Given?
Private:
Verbal notice is given prior to entering into the contract with the homeowner or lessee or at the time of signing the contract. Written notice is given before any work is performed, as it is part of the written contract, which must be executed before any work is performed. [444-25.5]
Public:
Not applicable.
6. Contents of Preliminary Notice.
Private:
Per a recent case, attorney fees and interest are not lienable. [Hill v. VNS Corp., 764 S.E.2d 876 [Ga.App. 2014)
Public:
Not applicable.
7. How Must Preliminary Notice Be Given?
Private:
Verbally, and then given to the homeowner or lessee in the form of a written contract. [444-25.5]
Public:
Not applicable.
8. Who Must Give Interim Notice?
Private:
An interim notice is not required.
Public:
An interim notice is not required.
9. Who Must Give Final Notice (Notice of Claim)?
Private:
All claimants. Takes form of “Application for a Lien” and “Notice of Lien.” [507-43] NOTE that a claimant may also file a Notice of Pendency of Action, which is recorded at the Bureau of Conveyances and which puts potential buyers of the property on notice that a claim has been made against the property. If, however, the lien is dismissed, the claimant – and possibly the claimant’s attorney – may be faced with a claim for slander of title or malicious prosecution. [Isobe v. Sakatani,279 P.3d 33 (HI App. 2012)] Note, however, that the lien is not automatically in place once it is filed. Notice is returnable 3-10 days after service, at which time a hearing is held to determine whether probable cause exists to permit the lien to attach. Only if the court finds probable cause does the lien attach. [507-43(a)]
Public:
Every claimant. [103D-324] As stated above, it is advisable to check with the public body letting the contract to see if there are any supplemental regulations. [Schor update at §12.01]
10. To Whom Is Final Notice Given?
Private:
-Owner(s) and person(s) contracting for improvements, and
-General contractor.
-Apply for the lien at circuit court. [507-43] NOTE that a claimant may also file a Notice of Pendency of Action, which is recorded at the Bureau of Conveyances and which puts potential buyers of the property on notice that a claim has been made against the property. If, however, the lien is dismissed, the claimant – and possibly the claimant’s attorney – may be faced with a claim for slander of title or malicious prosecution. [Isobe v. Sakatani,279 P.3d 33 (HI App. 2012)]
Public:
The contractor and the surety. [103D-324]
11. When Is Final Notice Given?
Private:
The notice must be received not later than 45 days after date of completion of project. If notice of completion is published and an affidavit of publication is filed with the circuit court clerk, then “date of completion” is date the owner or general completes publication of notice of and filing of affidavit. If notice is not filed or published within a year of actual completion or abandonment, then “date of completion” is one year after actual completion or abandonment. [507-43(b)]
Public:
The notice must be received within 90 days after claimant last furnishes labor or materials. [103D-324]
12. How Is Final Notice Given?
Private:
-Filed with the court.
-Served on owner(s) and people contracting for the work, in the manner prescribed for service of summons, but if any of these people can’t be served, then by posting on the improvement. Actual receipt of the notice if possible, or else posting, is required. Notice is returnable 3-10 days after service, at which time a hearing is held to determine whether probable cause exists to permit the lien to attach. Only if the court finds probable cause does the lien attach. In that case, the court then issues an Order Directing Lien to Attach. If the property in question is registered in the land court, AND if the lien is not solely against the interest of lessees of time share interests, then the claimant must file a certified copy of that Order with the office of the assistant registrar of the land court. [507-43]
Public:
Sent by registered or certified mail, or any manner authorized for serving summons. [103D-324]
13. Contents of Final Notice
Private:
-Amount of claim
-Labor or material furnished
-Description of property sufficient for identification
-Any other matter necessary to a clear understanding of the claim
-Name of assignor, if assigned
-Names of parties contracting for work
-Name of general contractor
-Name(s) of owner(s) and anyone with interest in the property
-Mortgages and other encumbrancers and general contractor’s surety may be named.
Notice of Lien: Sets forth alleged facts by virtue of which the claimant claims a lien. [507-43]
NOTE that a claimant may also file a Notice of Pendency of Action, which is recorded at the Bureau of Conveyances and which puts potential buyers of the property on notice that a claim has been made against the property. If, however, the lien is dismissed, the claimant – and possibly the claimant’s attorney – may be faced with a claim for slander of title or malicious prosecution. [Isobe v. Sakatani,279 P.3d 33 (HI App. 2012)]
Public:
-The amount claimed
-The name of the party to whom the labor or materials were furnished or supplied. [103D-324]
14. Time to Start Suit / Foreclose?
Private:
Within 3 months after entry of Order Directing Lien to Attach. [507-43, 507-47]
Public:
More than 90 days but less than one year after the claimant’s final delivery to the project. [103D.324]